Around this here corner of the intertubes, we make a living criticizing Mike Brown. As a matter of fact, stay tuned on that front because we have some very interesting information to share with you guys this week. Overall, Mike Brown is quite possibly the worst owner in all of American professional sports and has no business making personnel decisions on a day-to-day, year-to-year basis.
However, in any way you want to look at it, it's hard to knock the man for what he did this weekend. You can say he got lucky that certain guys essentially fell into his lap. A fair point. You can say a broken clock is right twice a day, which is certainly true. You could even point out that it was silly to make all 11 selections, because they can't all make the roster. I'd agree with you there.
Still, it's hard for me to take any sort of serious, sky-is-falling, negative outlook on the Bengals' draft in 2009. Obviously, we don't know how all of these guys will pan out. For all of their production at the college level, all picks in the NFL Draft have "bust" potential. However, to be perfectly honest, it would be hard for me to pin their failures on Mikey Boy.
Now, I know I'm just a guy who writes for a blog, but let's run down all 11 picks and I'll give my opinion. I could be wrong, I could be right, I could be grossly misinformed, but I'm going to do it anyway.
Round 1, Pick 6 - Andre Smith, OT, Alabama
As has been mentioned in this space before, Andre Smith was a consensus top 3 pick on January 1st. Then, he missed the Sugar Bowl, left the Combine, and took off his shirt. Now, don't get me wrong, there are some red flags with him. His weight is an issue, as is his maturity and motivation. However, you could find some red flags with all of the top flight tackles. Jason Smith basically never put his hand on the ground at Baylor. Some people questioned whether or not he'd transition well to the NFL. Eugene Monroe, for all of his talents, has knee problems which is obviously a huge concern for a man his size. Michael Oher has all-world upside but lacked consistency. Fact is, the Bengals needed a tackle. No matter which one they took, there was some downside. To be honest, I'd rather have Monroe, but it's hard to kill them for this pick.